thyme + butter
  • home
  • about
  • recipes
  • disclosure
  • recipe club
  • contact
  • dessert
  • winter

A Sticky Toffee Pudding to Warm Your Soul

I’ve been making Sticky Toffee Pudding as a winter tradition for about three years now, and at this point, I can’t imagine beginning the year without one! There’s just something about the rich, deep caramel flavor and ooey gooey texture that makes it the perfect cold weather dessert. It’s cozy, nostalgic, and indulgent, all the things I crave during the winter months!

If you’re unfamiliar, Sticky Toffee Pudding (or STP, as it’s sometimes called) is a classic British dessert, but don’t let the name fool you…there’s no actual pudding involved! Instead, it’s a beautifully tender cake made with dates, molasses, and a luxurious toffee sauce that soaks into every bite. It has the perfect balance of sweetness and warmth, and despite its simplicity, it delivers an unexpected depth of flavor!

I’ll admit, I’m usually not the biggest fan of caramel, but Sticky Toffee Pudding has completely won me over. The combination of earthy, sweet dates with the buttery toffee sauce creates something truly magical. If you’ve never tried it before, I highly encourage you to give it a go! You just might find a new favorite dessert to add to your own seasonal traditions!

This recipe is adapted from Nigella Lawson’s version, and it’s as foolproof as it is delicious. Let’s get baking!

Sticky Toffee Pudding to Warm Your Soul

DifficultyEasy

Servings6

Prep time30 minutes

Total time35 minutes

This classic Sticky Toffee Pudding recipe is rich, moist, and drenched in a luscious toffee sauce. Made with dates, molasses, and a hint of Earl Grey, it’s the perfect cozy dessert for winter!

sticky toffee pudding with caramel sauce

Ingredients

For the Cake

  • 8 ounces dates, pitted and chopped
  • 1 cup boiling water
  • 1 bag earl grey tea
  • 1 teaspoon baking soda
  • 6 tablespoons salted butter, room temperature
  • 2 tablespoons molasses
  • ¼ cup dark brown sugar
  • 2 large eggs, room temperature
  • 1¼ cups all-purpose flour
  • 2 teaspoons baking powder

For the Sauce

  • 10 tablespoons salted butter
  • 1½ cups dark brown sugar
  • 1 tablespoon molasses
  • 1 cup heavy cream

Instructions

  • 1

    Preheat oven to 350°F. Grease a 9×9 baking pan (glass or ceramic preferred) with butter or baking spray.

  • 2

    Boil 1 cup of water and steep the earl grey tea to package directions. Prepare your dates by removing pits and chopping into rough pieces, or if you’re lucky, you’ll have found pre-chopped dates. Pour tea over the dates and add in the baking soda. Set aside for at least 10 minutes while you prepare the other ingredients.

  • 3

    With a mixer, cream together the butter and brown sugar, about three minutes or until relatively smooth. Add in molasses. Then, once combined, add the eggs until well mixed.

  • 4

    Slowly add in the flour and baking powder, mixing until just combined.

  • 5

    Then, with a fork, stir your date mixture and break up any large chunks. The dates will have softened significantly. Add them into the mixer as well and continue mixing for about another minute.

  • 6

    Pour the batter into your greased baking dish and bake for 30-35 minutes, or until a toothpick comes out clean.

  • 7

    To make the sauce, combine butter, molasses, and sugar over low heat in a saucepan. Stir continuously, and once melted, add in the cream. Continue to stir until the sauce begins to bubble, then take it off the heat.

  • 8

    Once the cake is out of the oven, poke it all over with a toothpick and pour the caramel sauce over the top. You may have some sauce left over if your baking dish is on the shallow end. Extra sauce can be stored in the fridge and reheated once cooled.

  • 9

    Allow to cool for about 20 minutes before diving in.

Notes

TIP: Although it’s best right after baking, this pudding does keep well in the fridge. I do insist you always serve it warm, so be sure to microwave those 2nd day slices!


Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Hi! I'm Jess!

welcome to thyme + butter, a food and lifestyle blog dedicated to seasonal living and making everyday magic!

Join the recipe club!

Search

Latest recipes

  • The BEST Dark Chocolate Cake I've Ever Made

  • The Grand Roast Beef Sandwich with Onion Jam

  • A Sticky Toffee Pudding to Warm Your Soul

  • Meghan Markle's Decadent Pumpkin Fondue

  • New York Style Cheesecake with a Pumpkin Pie Swirl

Tags

christmas entertaining favorites homemaking knits & reads mindset pets the edit

Portrait of a Woman with Dill, 2025 mixed digital Portrait of a Woman with Dill, 2025
mixed digital media
courtesy of the artist
a few little moments from May 🥹🩷✨ a few little moments from May 🥹🩷✨
daffodils might just be my favorite part of spring daffodils might just be my favorite part of spring 🌼🧡
this (dare I say) perfect dark chocolate layer cak this (dare I say) perfect dark chocolate layer cake recipe is live on my substack! 🍫 you’ll want to be subscribed because I have a lot of delicious things to share this season! 🍰💕
winter reads + knits ❄️🧶 🌞 The Other Bo winter reads + knits ❄️🧶

🌞 The Other Boleyn Girl by @philippagregorybooks and Stripe Hype Sweater by @kutovakika in Knitting for Olive Merino in Mustard and Powder

🔮 A Fate Inked in Blood by @danielleljensen and #RebelSoulBeanie by Kutovakika in Sandnes Garn Double Sunday and Tynn Silk Mohair in Blackberry

🍯 Down The Drain by Julia Fox and another Rebel Soul Beanie by Kutovakika in #KnittingForOlive Merino and Soft Silk Mohair in Dusty Honey

#knitstagram #bookstagram #wips
wedding dress shopping should be considered an Oly wedding dress shopping should be considered an Olympic level sport 👰‍♀️🤸 but we found the dress! (Not pictured, obviously!) Swipe to slide 3 and tell me your favorite expression of the day 😂
merry christmas and happy new year from our frosty merry christmas and happy new year from our frosty little pup! 🎄🐾
it’s been real weird out here, but there are a f it’s been real weird out here, but there are a few little things bringing me joy recently:
🩵 true blue friends
🍒 cherry, our new little Portuguese Water Dog pup
🍰 celebrating our 6th (dating) and -1st wedding anniversaries (lmao)
🪡 crafting holiday gifts
🍊 making and baking
🎸 live music
💕 family and community

What #glimmers are you finding lately? ✨
your two favorite unlikely heroes (us) climbed cri your two favorite unlikely heroes (us) climbed cringe mountain (took practice engagement photos) and managed to survive unscathed (maybe actually pull it off?) 😂🩷
october reads + knits 🍂🧶 🍋‍🟩 People october reads + knits 🍂🧶

🍋‍🟩 People We Meet on Vacation by @emilyhenrywrites and the #milenabeanie by @karinatimeaknits in Sandnes Garn Sunday + Tynn Silk Mohair in Sunny Lime

💜 Margo’s Got Money Troubles by @rufithorpe and the #rebelsoulbeanie by @kutovakika in Rowan Alpaca Soft DK in Enchanted and KFO Soft Silk Mohair in Artichoke Purple

🌚 Slewfoot by @geraldbrom and another Rebel Soul Beanie in KFO Merino in Deep Petroleum Blue

#bookstagram #knitstagram
lessons from my garden this year🍐🥕🌷 1. Yo lessons from my garden this year🍐🥕🌷
1. You really can’t beat the satisfaction of building something from nothing.
2. When in doubt, choose the most colorful option.
3. A garden really doesn’t cost anything except time, money, blood, sweat, and tears.
4. It pays to plant your rows neatly, even if it takes twice the time.
5. Herbs and tomatoes are always a great start.
6. The juice will be worth the squeeze, especially if you like squeezing!
7. It’s true what they say... hoeing ain’t easy!
8. Pests come in all shapes and sizes. For us this year, it was wind and deer.
9. For a gardener, the saying should be “nothing is certain except death, taxes, ticks, and poison ivy”
10. When it comes to flowers and friends, the best ones are perennial 💐

What are you growing lately? 🩷
two days in Zermatt with lots of furry friends 🐑🐄🐕
🏔️💕 🏔️💕
started off Switzerland with Hospental and the Got started off Switzerland with Hospental and the Gotthard Pass 🫕✨🐄🇨🇭
three days in Venezia, Murano, and Burano 🇮🇹 three days in Venezia, Murano, and Burano 🇮🇹✨🍬
two days in Firenze 💕 museum hopping, bell towe two days in Firenze 💕 museum hopping, bell tower climbing, and fantastic food 🍨🇮🇹
bucket list item checked off in Florence 🐚✨ bucket list item checked off in Florence 🐚✨
two days in roma 🇮🇹 spritzes, strolling, and two days in roma 🇮🇹 spritzes, strolling, and a pasta making class! 🍝💕
summer highlight reel 🌞🎞️💕 summer highlight reel 🌞🎞️💕
teams meetings exist when nature is out there look teams meetings exist when nature is out there looking like this?? cruel and unusual!
Follow on Instagram

about the author

Jess Buckley is a Pennsylvania-based writer and home cook.

She loves the great outdoors, knitting, astrology, and all things vintage. You can usually find her in the kitchen, tending to her garden, browsing an antique mall, or relaxing with a cup of tea and a book about fairies.

Latest posts

  • The Best Bits: My April 2025 Favorites

  • Spring Cleaning Made Simple: A Realistic Home Refresh

Latest recipes

  • The BEST Dark Chocolate Cake I've Ever Made

  • The Grand Roast Beef Sandwich with Onion Jam

  • about
  • contact
  • disclosure
  • privacy policy

© 2025 | Jess Buckley