thyme and butter
  • home
  • about
  • recipes
  • disclosure
  • recipe club
  • shop
  • classics
  • lunch

Life Changing Tuna Salad

Tuna is an incredibly versatile yet totally polarizing fish. There aren’t many other meats that can be served raw in five star restaurants and also included with crackers in a child’s lunchbox. Tuna is a picnic and sandwich staple, yet it’s jokingly (or maybe seriously) forbidden from planes and networking functions.

People generally feel one of three ways about tuna salad. They either really love it, completely hate it, or feel indifferent to it. I was always on team three, finding it interchangeable with similar mayo based salads like chicken or egg. That was until I found this recipe!

I’m here to shift that indifference and move everyone’s meter all the way over to tuna salad love. If you’re like my best friend Emily, you’ll love this tuna salad so much it will change your life! (Her words, not mine!)

I will give you a small warning though, this tuna salad is not subtle by any means. I would not recommend you eat it before a first date, a job interview, or any sort of function that involves making a good impression with your breath. You can, however, serve it to guests and get funky together. It’s a bonding experience!

This recipe is adapted from Ultimate Tuna Melts by Ina Garten. My version would be fantastic with toasty bread and cheese too, but I don’t find those necessary to enjoy it!

Life Changing Tuna Salad

DifficultyEasy

Servings4

Prep time23 minutes

This tuna salad is packed with fresh ingredients and a ton of flavor. It might just change your life.

Ingredients

  • 10 to 12 ounces canned tuna
  • 3 green onions, chopped
  • 3 tablespoons fresh dill, chopped
  • 2 tablespoons lemon juice
  • ½ cup mayonnaise
  • 1 teaspoon anchovy paste
  • salt and pepper to taste

Instructions

  • 1

    Add the canned tuna to a bowl and separate any chunks gently with a fork. Then, add in chopped green onions and dill. Mix in lemon juice, mayo, and anchovy paste.

  • 2

    Top with a generous amount of cracked pepper and your preferred amount of salt. Serve with crackers, on a sandwich, or with toasted pita for dipping.


Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Hi! I'm Jess!

welcome to thyme and butter, a food and lifestyle blog dedicated to savoring the seasons and living for the little things!

Join the recipe club!

Search

Latest recipes

  • The Best Chocolate Peanut Butter Eggs (Reece's Dupe!)

  • It's a Fondue Party! (Cheese Fondue for Six)

Tags

christmas entertaining favorites homemaking knits & reads mindset pets the edit

my most popular recipes! What are you cooking late my most popular recipes! What are you cooking lately?
all my current knitting #WIPs! What are you making all my current knitting #WIPs! What are you making lately? 🧶💕 #knitstagram
peanut butter eggs that might just be better than peanut butter eggs that might just be better than that one famous brand 😉

recipe:
2 cups sugar
½ cup milk
¼ cup butter
6 ounces peanut butter
3 oz marshmallow creme
⅓ cup all-purpose flour
1 bag chocolate chips or melting wafers

Add sugar, milk, and butter to a saucepan over medium heat. Bring to a boil and stir continuously for 5 mins, then remove from heat.

Stir in peanut butter and marshmallow creme, then slowly incorporate flour and stir until combined.

Pour mixture onto a pan lined with parchment paper and allow to cool for about 30 minutes. When cool enough to handle, shape into eggs, insert a toothpick into each one, and allow to set completely. Then chill in the fridge or freezer for an hour or more to avoid any melting when dipped.

Melt the chocolate, dip each egg, allow to harden and enjoy! 🍫😋
little water dog meets great lake 🌅 little water dog meets great lake 🌅
postcards from hibernation season ❄️⛄️🌨️ postcards from hibernation season ❄️⛄️🌨️
our wedding was a little over a month ago and I’m our wedding was a little over a month ago and I’m just now going through some of the photos! We had the best day filled with so much love from our friends and family 💕 there were millions of bubbles, thousands of cookies, a handful of distracting roosters, one rogue donkey, TWO swords, and more happy memories than we can count!
we did it! 💕 we did it! 💕
frickin’ bats 🦇🎃 frickin’ bats 🦇🎃
this season of life has been all about the texture this season of life has been all about the textures ✨🐞
it’s been the best summer on record, and that’s th it’s been the best summer on record, and that’s the caption 🫐🌞💕
little summer moments 🌞💕 little summer moments 🌞💕
Cherry always looks out for number one, and we wou Cherry always looks out for number one, and we wouldn’t have it any other way! 😂🩷🍒 #portuguesewaterdog #portiesofinstagram
I highly recommend going to summer camp with your I highly recommend going to summer camp with your best friends 🥰
sappy post incoming: I was given the opportunity t sappy post incoming: I was given the opportunity to spend a long weekend in the mountains with some of my most favorite people on the planet. These are the ladies that never fail to remind me of the magic of life. I can’t express how much it means to me that they gathered to spend time in nature and be silly with me. My heart is full and my face hurts still hurts from smiling! And as the song says… it’s in our nature to look out for each other in the heart of the woods 💕🌲
had the most fun photo session with @kellyspaine a had the most fun photo session with @kellyspaine and as expected, Cherry was ready for her close up! 🥰🍒
we took Cherry on her first ever hiking trip and s we took Cherry on her first ever hiking trip and she absolutely loved it! The trail was a bit rockier than we expected, but she climbed them all like a champ! She even made some friends while she enjoyed her breakfast at the summit 🥹🍒🪨🌿
my favorite new spring tradition: making rhubarb j my favorite new spring tradition: making rhubarb jam and strawberry preserves 🍓🫙💕
Portrait of a Woman with Dill Portrait of a Woman with Dill
a few little moments from May 🥹🩷✨ a few little moments from May 🥹🩷✨
had plans to post the fun pillow I thrifted, but a had plans to post the fun pillow I thrifted, but a little someone decided to steal the spotlight 😝🌸🩷
Follow on Instagram

about the author

Jess Buckley is a Pennsylvania-based writer and home cook that finds joy in sharing her love for cooking, gardening, and seasonal-inspired living.

Latest posts

  • The Best Bits: My February 2026 Favorites

  • The Best Bits: My January 2026 Favorites

Latest recipes

  • The Best Chocolate Peanut Butter Eggs (Reece's Dupe!)

  • It's a Fondue Party! (Cheese Fondue for Six)

  • about
  • disclosure
  • privacy policy

© 2026 | thyme and butter studio